🏡 Should I Buy or Rent in Central PA? Here’s What to Consider in 2025

ByTeam Sechman

Thinking about making a move in Annville, Palmyra, or Hershey?

A distressed couple sits by a car full of boxes, symbolizing moving stress.

One of the biggest questions people ask is: “Should I buy or rent a home right now?”

With rising rents, fluctuating interest rates, and a competitive market, the answer depends on a few key factors — especially here in Central Pennsylvania.

In this post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of buying vs. renting, based on local market trends in 2025.

🔍 Why This Question Matters in Annville, Palmyra & Hershey

If you’re living in or relocating to the Lebanon Valley, you’ve probably seen how fast housing prices have shifted in the last few years. But what many don’t realize is how homeownership can build long-term wealth, especially in small-town markets with strong demand.

Whether you’re a first-time buyer or just tired of paying rent, here’s what you need to know:

âś… Pros of Buying a Home in Central PA
1. Equity Growth Over Time

Home values in Annville and Palmyra have steadily increased, even during national market slowdowns. When you buy, you’re investing in an asset that could grow in value year over year.

đź“Š According to recent data, homes in Lebanon County appreciated by over 6% in the past 12 months.

2. Stable Monthly Payments

With a fixed-rate mortgage, your monthly payment stays the same — unlike rent, which often increases yearly.

3. Tax Benefits

Homeowners may qualify for deductions on mortgage interest, property taxes, and more — reducing your total tax burden.

4. Freedom to Personalize

No need to ask a landlord before painting the walls or installing new flooring. It’s your space, your call.

đźš« Cons of Buying
  • Requires upfront costs: down payment, closing costs, inspections
  • Maintenance and repairs are your responsibility
  • Less flexibility if you need to move quickly
âś… Pros of Renting in Annville, Palmyra, or Hershey
1. Lower Upfront Cost

Renting usually requires just first month’s rent and a security deposit.

2. Flexibility

Planning to relocate for work or school? Renting gives you the option to move without selling a home.

3. No Maintenance Headaches

If the furnace breaks or the roof leaks — that’s your landlord’s problem, not yours.

đźš« Cons of Renting
  • No equity gained over time
  • Subject to rent increases or non-renewals
  • Limited control over upgrades or personalization
  • You’re paying toward someone else’s investment, not your own
💡 What’s the Market Saying in 2025?

In Central PA, low inventory and consistent demand are still driving prices. But interest rates have stabilized, making it a great time for buyers with strong credit and financial preparation.

Here’s what we’re seeing:

  • First-time buyers are using FHA and PHFA programs to buy with as little as 3% down
  • Renters are getting priced out of apartments in Hershey and Palmyra
  • Investors are scooping up multi-units in Annville due to strong rental demand
🧠 So… Should You Buy or Rent?

If you plan to stay in the area for at least 2–3 years, buying can be the smarter financial move — especially with the opportunity to build equity, lock in monthly costs, and invest in your future.

Still unsure?

đź“… Schedule a Free Buyer Consultation

We’ll sit down, look at your budget, your goals, and the local market — and help you make a confident decision.

Book a Buyer Consultation
Search Homes